Mobilizing the Region
Issue 30April 14, 1995



Transit Advocates Charge NYC Transit Conceals Massive Cuts


Transit advocacy organizations and NYC Public Advocate Mark Green last week charged New York City Transit officials of distributing pamphlets and posters that deliberately conceal massive cuts planned for city transit services. The pamphlets and posters advertise the public hearings legally required before transit service cuts can be effected, and are available at all 469 subway stations. But the pamphlets deliberately omit mention of service cuts on 11 subway lines and 97 bus schedules. While the pamphlets tell riders that cuts are targeted at "lightly used" bus routes and subway services "during late night hours," the concealed cuts will affect many riders during rush hour and peak period service. At a Times Square news conference, Green said that transit riders had a right to know how proposed service reductions will affect them. "Transit officials are committing consumer fraud," said Gene Russianoff of the Straphangers Campaign. "They don't want thousands of riders to know they will suffer longer waits and more crushing crowding if these cuts go through."

An April 12 Straphangers Campaign/NYC Transit Riders Council letter to MTA Chair Peter Stangl requested postponement of the service cut hearings scheduled to start April 27, and a recall of the misleading information being distributed by NYC Transit. The letter cited section 1205(7) of New York's Public Authorities Law, which says posted notices on service changes are to "fairly and accurately convey the basic nature of such changes." The letter says "hearings under such circumstances (undisclosed service cuts) would show contempt for the riding public."
 

Announced Cuts

Hidden Cuts

Subway

5 lines

11 lines (fewer trains per hour)

 

(3 lines: no late-night service; 2 lines "restructured")

1995 reductions: $.8 million

   

1996 reductions: $2.7 million

 

1 station closed (Dean Street)

 
 

Total 1995 reductions: $.38 million

 
 

Total 1996 reductions: $1.5 million

 
 

22 token booths closed

 

Bus

39 routes

61 routes (fewer buses per hour)

 

(28 routes: fewer hours;

Total 1995 reductions: $2.3 million

 

3 routes: eliminated;

Total 1996 reductions: $7.7 million

 

8 routes: shortened)

35 routes (violate crowding guidelines)

 

1995 total: $2.3 million

1995 total: $.7 million

 

1996 total: $7.8 million

1996 total: $2.3 million

 

Express buses eliminated

 
 

(non-Staten Island routes)

 
 

1995: $2.3 million

 
 

1996: $7.8 million

 

TOTALS

1995: $8.2 million

1995: $7.5 million

 

Hidden reductions are 45% of NYC Transit cuts in 1995

 
 

1996: $27.1 million

1996: $24.8 million

 

Hidden reductions are 47% of NYC Transit cuts in 1996

 
 

($ figures do not include savings from token booth closures)

 
Meanwhile, NY Newsday called for a "transit summit" in a lengthy Sunday editorial. Arguing that NY State and City leaders must come together to find a way to fully fund a new multi-year MTA operating and capital investment plan, the paper called the downstate region's rapid rail system "invaluable" and warned against the economic folly of repeating the 1970s cycle of disinvestment. The piece called for Governor Pataki to lift his suspension of the MTA's bonding authority, and get the transit capital program moving again. It called on the legislature to renew the corporate franchise tax surcharge, scheduled to expire in November, as dedicated MTA revenue. NY Newsday also supported shifting more MTA bridge and tunnel revenue from the suburbs to the city and lifting Pataki's moratorium on commuter rail fare hikes. It also said the MTA should revise the timeline for implementing the Fare Deal monthly fare pass program, rather than to abandon it all together.



Calendar of EventsLast ArticleTable of ContentsNext ArticleBack to Main Page