Mobilizing the Region

Issue 185 August 14, 1998



Recovering the Costs of Gridlock

In MTR #183 , we discussed East River bridge tolls at some length. Below we present estimates of net revenues for a variety of toll scenarios for New York City's free bridges to Manhattan. They were developed by Charles Komanoff, an economist associated with the Tri-State Transportation Campaign, and Jim Tripp of the Environmental Defense Fund as the MTA prepared to raise transit fares in Autumn, 1995.

Net Revenues from Tolling
East River Bridges
OPTIONS annual NYC revenue gain (millions) at $3.50 toll
East and Harlem River tolls at current MTA Bridges & Tunnels rate ¾ no new discounts.

$770

50% discount for Harlem River bridges

$575

50% discount for off-peak crossings (but eliminate TBTA EZ-Pass, bulk, resident and carpool discounts)

$670

Both discounts above (but eliminate TBTA EZ-Pass, bulk, resident and carpool discounts)

$500

Figures reflect estimated $50 million cost to City to administer, operate and amortize NYC toll facilities.

The MTA would also gain revenue (NYC DOT estimated $90 million net per year in 1991) due to reduced diversion to tolled City bridges, but the gain would be lessened somewhat in off-peak discount scenarios. Figures may be understated, since trucks are treated same as cars. Calculated from baseline data in NYC Department of Transportation, Funding the Capital and Operating Needs of New York City's Bridges and Streets, Oct. 1991.





Calendar of EventsLast ArticleTable of ContentsNext ArticleBack to Main Page