On October 19th, the Poughkeepsie Journal reported that Metro North's Hudson Line Extension study is on hold. "In light of the opposition expressed by residents in the study area, Metro North is reassessing the study," said Marjorie Anders, a spokeswoman for Metro North.

But James Sedore, the Dutchess County representative to the MTA board said that the study "has not been scrubbed." He expects that officials from Dutchess County and the MTA will meet sometime over the next two months to decide "how to proceed in the best interests of the County."

Scores of residents in Northern Dutchess communities have voiced opposition at public meetings held by Metro North. They have cited concerns that expanded commuter service would induce sprawl. In addition, there is concern that a terminus in the small riverfront communities of Tivoli and Rhinecliff would overwhelm the riverfront. Six municipalities have passed formal resolutions opposing the $3 million environmental impact statement/major investment study.

Dutchess County Executive William Steinhaus and Columbia County officials suggested that the study examine a longer extension to Hudson, the seat of Columbia County. However, since Columbia County is outside of Metro North's charter, an extension to Hudson will not be considered.