Mobilizing the Region
Issue 307 March 5, 2001


Brooklyn Traffic Calming Plan: Still Contested

Transportation Alternatives' Winter, 2001 magazine reports that Downtown Brooklyn pilot traffic calming projects are finally being implemented. But the organization warns that the projects' designs have been so diluted that community groups wonder whether they will have any impact on car speeds or through-traffic volumes.

Traffic calming in NYC has suffered from conflicting impulses among city transportation managers. The need to better protect pedestrians and neighborhood character from burgeoning traffic is obvious, yet a strong "car party" within the transportation bureaucracy seems clearly uncomfortable with the reversal of traditional traffic engineering that traffic calming represents. Thus, promising speed hump deployment has slowed down, and was criticized by former city Transportation Commissioner Wilbur Chapman (MTR #245).

The NYC DOT's Downtown Brooklyn traffic calming project has ridden the same waves, and has been a subject of controversy for years. Brooklyn civic leaders, elected officials and pedestrian advocates had to fight hard to keep the city from scuttling the project altogether (see MTR #114), and as recently as last summer, DOT officials said they hoped any traffic calming measures would affect traffic as little as possible (MTR #269).

Downtown Brooklyn Traffic Calming Projects
  • Curb extensions on Lafayette Ave. at Carlton Avenue and Adelphi Street, and at the intersection of Hicks Street and Atlantic Avenue.
  • A raised intersection at Hicks Street and Pierrepont Street.
  • A neckdown and raised crosswalk on South Oxford Street at Fulton Street.
  • Widened median refuges on Tillary Street at Adams, and longer pedestrian signal phases.
  • A pedestrian refuge on Atlantic Avenue at Bond Street, and neckdowns on Bond Street at Atlantic Ave.
  • A colored bicycle lane on Henry Street south of Atlantic Avenue.
  • A leading pedestrian interval at Atlantic Avenue and Clinton Street.
  • An exclusive pedestrian phase at Remsen Street and Court Street.

  • Public meetings to discuss the pilot projects will be held this spring. Contact Transportation Alternatives at 212-629-8080 or transalt.org for more information.

T.A. says the projects the city is promoting in Brooklyn represent only the mildest traffic calming measures. For instance, raised crosswalk and intersection applications are only two inches high, as opposed to the international standard of four inches. DOT has also refused to install sidewalk-extending "neckdowns" at many of the intersections where they would be most effective. The Department also shies away from bollards at streetcorners, arguing that they could create problems for "speeding motorists."
 


MTR SearchCalendar of EventsLast ArticleTable of ContentsNext ArticleBack to Main Page